why did joker kill randall

The ending is a scene before the actual movie. He lifts Bruces mouth into a twisted smile in a similar way he does when putting his clown make-up on in his dressing room at the start of the movie. (24 kg) of weight? Killing a money laundering rat like Lao by burning him with the very same money he helped crime lords abscond with is the minimum required atrocity by an extreme villain with a violent reputation. Edit, If you mean the series of films starting with 1989's Batman, that's another timeline. But in reality, he is painfully inept and even repulsive. Joaquin played the role perfectly. This shows us that it is not an imagination of Arthur or a misinterpretation but rather that Randall is fully aware of his role in handing the gun over to Arthur.Most of these contacts are also contrasted by Gary. He also likely repressed a lot, even buying the Thomas is actually his father theory that still means we have no idea where Arthur was when she stayed at the asylum, how he contacted her and ended up living with her. This is an indictment of American television and the mind-numbing incessant sameness of every day's formulaic show -- a conformity of First Amendment rights to people's sense of propriety. Since Joker had his spin off movie, is it possible that the Riddler might have a spin off movie? | Edit, She was real, but only his first meeting with her in the elevator, the stalking and her final scene in her apartment (when she questions him about his name) happened. While Arthur Fleck isnt a villain at the start of the movie, whats made clear is that he suffers from mental illness. A sigh of relief. If the police wouldn't understand why Arthur had a gun how would they expect him to be in a situation where he had to cause a self defense murder, If a sequel happens is it possible they may have a Robin make a small appearance in a joker sequel. Arthur had his signboard taken from him by a group of teens of colour, who proceeded to beat him up. Leaving out "the" introduces a necessary ambiguity; after all, a key part of most versions of the Joker is that no one, not even he, truly know knows who he is or where he comes from. It's possible he was incapable of any human emotion anymore, besides, it would seem, glee at destruction, mayhem, and homicide. To his credit, Arthur allows David escape in one of the only (darkly) funny scenes of the whole movie. How to combine several legends in one frame? This films many similarities to 'The King Of Comedy' ,filmed in 1981 & released in 1982 may also be a pointer to the time it is set. Randal is a clown-for-hire who works for Haha, the same entertainment business in which Arthur Fleck works for. Perhaps he even expected his crew to check for weapons, but they slipped up. Is Thomas Wayne considered an antagonist in this film? The first scene we see Randall, as he hands Arthur a gun, Randall has an evil smile on his face while suggesting Arthur "pays him back sometime", followed up with "you know you're my boy." which triggers Arthur's laugh. It might all be a lie and that he accepted the abuse claim since he got tired of her.2.) She turns around with an annoyed look on her face while Arthur laughs, like it's an inconvenience for her. The Joker in comic book canon has been quoted as saying that if he had to have a past, he would prefer that it be multiple choice. Outlander: 10 Things That Make No Sense About Jack Randall - Screen Rant Edit, This Joker is a completely standalone non-canon take on the character. When Arthur smothers his mother in the hospital, she's wearing a nasal cannula presumably hooked up to oxygen - how did she asphyxiate? Randall is the secondary antagonist of the 2019 psychological thriller film Joker. Joker (2019) - Plot - IMDb Thomas' actor even stated in interviews he played the character as if he was Arthur's father. [Spoiler] Joker (2019) movie: Why did Arthur Fleck kill his - Quora It's not established Penny's not Arthur/Joker's biological mother and that she ever lied about her relationship with Thomas Wayne. Randall is shown to be so concerned for Arthur's well-being after he gets beaten that he gives him the firearm to defend himself. Why didn't Arthur respond in shock to Sophie not knowing his name when he was in her apartment? Everything between that was in his head. Edit, Possibly. This means that no one really knows where he came from and this gives an aura of mystery to the character. Did Randall actually plan to set up Arthur to get him fired? Up until that point Arthur has only been killing people he perceived as responsible for his situation (his mother, Randall, subway attackers). Did Thomas Wayne really have an affair with Penny? Can someone explain what the red footprints were at the end along the corridor and then the running about at the end of the corridor? Is Thomas Wayne really Arthur's father, and due to his wealthy status forged adoption papers? The movie audience would then go away with a sense that this is what mental illness does to people, without the concept of grandeur or the understanding that this was the origin story of some villain. Joker doesnt flinch as he drives a pair of scissors into his former boss eye and proceeds to repeatedly slam his head again a wall before he bleeds out. He's an unreliable narrator who has a poor relationship with his mother. Or different Batman characters who eventually become a Joker? Arthur killed his mother in a pre-meditated way as he snuffed her out with a pillow in the hospital. Its enough to prompt one of his laughing fits and when his psychiatrist asks whats so funny, he eerily says "You wouldnt get it." (B) A competent defense lawyer (assuming Arthur could get one) could likely get the first two killings ruled justifiable homicides, but the third man he killed was retreating; pursuing him and finishing him off with malice aforethought as Arthur did is murder in the first degree according to the laws of every state in the USA. Followed by beating him until all he can do is lay on the ground in pain. Could Thomas Wayne have forced Penny to sign fake adoption papers to cover up the child born out of wedlock? Are those cigarettes real? Sher continued, "In terms of what we did visually to play with the real and not real, there are callbacks and scenes that mirror each other. The character suffers from a condition that means hes unable to prevent bursting into laughter in even the most awkward situations and, as youd expect, he gets a fair bit of attention whenever this happens. Edit, He certainly could, but: Its unclear whether or not he kills her and her young child but given we see sirens flashing outside in the following scene, its likely that he killed her. Phoenix revealed that is the standard way he loses weight for a role.It is not uncommon for dedicated actors to go through seemingly extreme weight loss for a part (former Batman Christian Bale in 'The Machinist' for example) .Because of the costs involved with making these films ,insurance requirements & partly due to Heath ledgers death after previously playing the Joker, the Physical & mental wellbeing while under contract is monitored very closely by the production companies involved. Arthur and his mother live in poverty, so how could they afford to own both an answering machine and a videocassette recorder? Woodlands had dinosaurs before it was cool. It's also a callback to the first friendly moment he had (or imagined having) with her, when they commiserate about how bad it is to live in an old building with problems like an erratic elevator, and she makes the gesture as a self-revealing way to show how sick of it she is. If youve ever wanted to shoot your shot at being an influencer, nows your chance. Since this movie takes place through Arthur's eyes, and he is shown to be a far from reliable and unbiased observer, however, one might do well to take these opinions with a grain of salt. She may also have been gifted it as a way to work from home or a parting giftEdit: She worked for the Waynes 30 years before the events of this movie (although in the flashback, she doesn't look like she's living in the early fifties). He didn't know that Arthur brought a gun with him, and there were several other people in the studio. The Sophie twist puts into question just how much of the events depicted on screen are taking place inside of Arthur's head and how much are real. In Arthur's mind, he imagines himself as a normal person. RELATED: Joker's Backlash Ended Up Being A Marketing Trick. Arthur was denied access to his mother's medical records by a black clerk -- those files revealed Arthur's adopted status. Edit, It's unlikely. He probably didn't believe Arthur and assumed that he misplaced or broke the sign. Joker 's ending leaves the truth of the DC villain's origin almost as mysterious as before it began. they are saying it is too violent and empty). Was Gary actually the only person who was nice to Arthur throughout the whole movie? Edit, The film's script clarifies that while his producer tries to end the interview, Murray refuses because he believes that it's making great television and that he may win an Emmy or a Peabody for it. ** Use in-universe knowledge, rules, and common sense to answer the questions. Edit, Two possibilities: Why is the film just called "Joker" and not "The Joker"? The supremely dark new movie "Joker" is the type of flick that offers itself up to many interpretations - both positive and negative. Edit, It's indicated that Arthur himself never truly believed they were together, that's when we finally know that it had actually only been Arthur fantasizing about her all along.Alternatively, it could be that he was numb from so many traumatic events (beatdowns and tauntings, murdering people, investigation by the police, losing his job, losing/killing his mother, being mocked on national TV, rejection from the Wayne family, not to realize his whole abusive crazy childhood) that realizing Sophie didn't actually know him was just one more rejection and loss piled on. Initially, all signs point to Joaquin Phoenixs character offing himself on live television to make a grand statement about mental illness and society, with Arthur even putting a gun to his head by a way of practice. That's exactly what Arthur alludes to right before he shoots him. There was a super rat scurrying across the side of the building in the bottom-right corner of the scene when Arthur was in the phone booth explaining why he had a gun and then getting fired. Sometimes, the episodes may switch between emotional states, resulting in the patient crying uncontrollably before dissolving into fits of laughter. So at the end of the movie, was all this Joker stuff all just a dream or a daydream in Arthur's head? Arthur will be an old man by the time Bruce becomes the dark knight. "I could tell you a joke, but you wouldn't get it. When Arthur suffocated his mother in hospital and her pulse flatlined, there was no one around to intervene (assuming this murder did take place and wasn't just in Arthur's head). Three rich bankers: For sure Arthur did those as their deaths were acknowledged on television and by Thomas Wayne, as mayor-wannabe. How to check for #1 being either `d` or `h` with latex3? The point is that he threw Arthur under the bus even when he didn't need to. Theory on Randall : r/joker - Reddit May as well try and see how the maniac's mind works.4.) A key point of the movie is that it gradually becomes clear that we cannot entirely trust anything we've seen. Edit, Gotham could possibly have its own Wall Street. Edit, No. In Joker (2019), why did Randall give the Joker the gun? When he killed Randall, he did not kill his other colleague who was present in the room, despite the fear that he could go to the police. Edit, Yes, it is possible, but considering how things develop and are revealed through the film this all seems highly unlikely and if it were true, then it would give the viewing audience no clue. Moreover, these three deaths were trophy kills for Arthur as he openly talked about them, almost as if he was claiming credit. But this only serves to bring out the blandness and correctness of Murray Franklin, who as a consummate showman, also pulls off terrible one-liners. He is visited in his apartment by Randall and another former co-worker, a dwarf named Gary (Leigh Gill). Just when he thinks he's caught up to them in an alleyway, they smash the sign over his face. The Joker famously said in "The Killing Joke" that his origin story is "multiple choice," and this movie certainly upholds that claim with a vengeance for Arthur Fleck (mostly by making him an unreliable narrator and leaving the audience to guess how much of what it's seeing is real and how much is just hallucinatory or a self-serving memory). Maybe his madness going further? Because if he was, that scene must be in his head. And Arthur could presumably have bought more ammunition in the days between first getting the gun and killing Murray.There is also the possibility that the events of the subway killing happened differently than as portrayed. Here, we see Arthur struggle with his rattling laughter, trying but failing to control it as it tears through him. when he climbs into the fridge, there is very little food inside. With that in mind we now take a look at the 10 worst things Arthur does throughout the movie to turn him not just into a bad person, but Gotham City's feared Clown Prince of Crime. Edit, Although it's never mentioned in the film, it's heavily implied that Arthur may have anorexia nervosa, which is a disorder that affects women and men. What is the exact timeline of the Joker movie universe? New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. Only in the last scene Arthur will spare him because he never was mean towards Arthur.Based on that logic, the last encounter of the trio gave Gary and Randall what they deserveSo Randall lied that Arthur got it from someone else and that Arthur even tried to buy one from Randall. 2) Arthur's actual age isn't as old as Phoenix and he just looks that way because he's unwell and a smoker; Fleck could begin taking care of himself and be a villain for a very young Batman (depending on Canon Batman starts at 25, so if Fleck is just an old looking 35, he would be 52 when "Year One" takes place). When Arthur admitted on Murray's show that he killed the three Wall Street guys on subway why didn't he simply say it was self defense that way someone would understand how Arthur became Joker? He probably knew that he was gonna die either way. Arthur can't blame all his decision on other people being jerks or his illnesses some are his own poor judgement, like not reporting the beatdown to the store owner or calling the cops about it. Like much else in this movie, whether this is *THE* Joker's origin story or just *A* Joker's origin story is left to the audience to guess. About (E) Unless he or his lawyer could somehow locate that woman the men were harassing and get her to come testify on his behalf, he'd have no one to testify to his claims but himself; and again, he's known to be extremely unreliable. We leave hints using imagery or way we covered scenes similarly between scene. Unlike regular superhero movies, (Shazam, Suicide Squad or any other Marvel movie), there is no one transformative moment in Arthur's story that made him the Joker. Edit, The movie appears to be set in 1980's Gotham City, which is heavily inspired by New York in that time period. "Joker" centers around the iconic arch-nemesis and is an original, standalone story not seen before on the big screen. Did she have this procedure before the abuse took place and could this explain how the abuse could happen without her stopping it? The total number of cases in Singapore stands at 57,915. 's required for entrance to all business offices, etc. One thing I didn't quite understand in Joker was why Randall betrayed Arthur so quickly when the gun was found. VASPKIT and SeeK-path recommend different paths. Joker doesnt like this one bit and grabs Waynes confidant by the tie before proceeding to strangle him while a dumbstruck Bruce looks on. Many think that the clerk in Arkham Asylum was fairly nice to Arthur, in searching for his mother's records. Touching kids you dont know and playing with their face? Answer (1 of 3): No. Joker Ending Explained: What Happened at the End of Joker? Edit, There is none. A broken and frustrated Arthur apologizes for his intrusion and leaves Sophie alone, storming out of her apartment. If 'Joker' made you feel uncomfortable, here's why This is why audiences are blown away by Joanquin Phoenix's performance -- if they watch the movie another time. Trivia By clicking Accept all cookies, you agree Stack Exchange can store cookies on your device and disclose information in accordance with our Cookie Policy. | That's the true end to the story. Joker: Why Arthur Fleck Doesn't Kill Sophie - Screen Rant Arthur gets away with it, too, with it presumed that doctors believed she died as a result of her stroke rather than anything much more sinister. A place to discuss all things related to DC's Joker character. While not murdering is a positive, strangling the guy for doing his job is just plain wrong. A little bit like the William Hung experience on "American Idol". The pacing of the movie and the character development of Arthur is almost Birdman-like. He just thought he was being silly with a guy who did a silly thing. When Arthur and Murray first meet each other, you can see that Murray is very respectful . I saw Brett Cullen in this movie as Thomas Wayne and as a character in Dark knight rises. In order to discover whether or not this is true, he takes a trip to Wayne Manor and meets Bruce Wayne for the first time on the other side of a well-polished metallic gate. This is the only time we see Joker without his make up, but the scars on his face are clearly visible. But as a political statement that the victims of oppression and economic destitution in 1980s Gotham City, which is a mirror of New York city, are predominantly black? Edit, He never saw Arthur as reliable because of his mental condition. , as well as the fact that Bruce's actor played a young Joaquin in another film. In the first act of the film, we see Arthur's fantasy of meeting Murray play out on the screen, and perhaps this is just another case of that. And Joker unlocked the door for him and then kissed him on the head. Randall gave the gun to Arthur for money (which he intended to demand from him later). While some version of these events may have happened, there's no concrete evidence that they played out in any way like we see in the film, they could just be what Arthur believes / wishes happened. Jonathan "Black Jack" Randall was the key antagonist in the first three seasons of Starz series Outlander. and our There's also the likelihood of (physical) trauma-induced amnesia or he simply repressed the memory. Brett Cullen and Joaquin Phoenix have an age difference of about 20 years, so this could realistically be true.However, it would imply a large deviation from the comics by making Arthur Bruce's brother. Think about that - he had a laminated card to explain his condition in the 1980's. Why is Joaquin Phoenix's version of Joker wearing a red suit doesn't Joker always wear purple? If this was the case, it would also explain why Randalls death was the most brutal and drawn out, compared to everyone else. This would validate the murder a bit, at least in his mind. Also in those records are some newspaper clippings that reveal Arthur was three years old when the authorities learned that his mother's boyfriend abused them. He did not. The debate over Zazie Beetz's fate in "Joker" came to an end last month when cinematographer Lawrence Sher said her character, Sophie, was not killed by Joaquin Phoenix's Arthur. In the movie, Arthur Fleck's mental condition was repeatedly triggered by people of colour. | Copyright 2020 Mothership. Either way, the scene really hammers in how Arthur doesn't really have a chance in the world of Gotham. He was an 18th-century military captain in charge of His Majesty's Eighth Dragoons. 2) It's from all the abuse he suffered from his mothers boyfriend when he was younger. It's not impossible he just never met her again until he was an adult after she was committed rightfully or not and tried to live back a fantasy. His attempt to shoot the Mayor is foiled by Gordon. Another one of his "jokes" (visions/episodes/whathaveyou) was more than likely the killing of the therapist, hence the whacky running back and forth through the hallways with the single bodyguard. Comments Fincher made shows that he did not like the film, criticizing it as another Hollywood franchise film that steals from more original films, namely Taxi Driver and the King of Comedy. She reminded Arthur that her young daughter was sleeping in their bedroom and the film reveals that Sophie and Arthur, in fact, barely know each other. Nevertheless, it works brilliantly as a metaphor for being born again. Randall sounds genuinely sympathetic towards Arthur at first, before its discovered its merely a ruse and that he paid the visit to learn what the police know about his firearm. He would expect his crew to be running for help at this point as his stage manager was questioning whether or not Arthur was a good guest to have. More broadly speaking, Wayne's publicly stating on television that Gotham's underclass were "clowns" like that guy who murdered those three brokers from his company (referring to Fleck, though Wayne didn't know he was that guy at the time) certainly made him seem "rude" in their eyes as well. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. (C) Even if his lawyer could arrange some kind of plea-bargain deal to get his sentence for the third killing reduced, Arthur's using a gun he was not legally allowed to own (due to his being mentally ill) would also earn him some further prison time and civil penalties. Joker (2019) | Villains Wiki | Fandom When Arthur confessed to the clerk in the Arkham State Hospital that he killed three people, the first reaction wasn't to call the police. "We wanted to make the interpretation of the real versus what's not real, a part of the viewer's experience," Sher recently told /Film. Viewers have offered several possibilities:1.) Arthur was lying in bed touching himself when the personnel from the Murray Franklin show called him at home. Does he feel she lied to him about his father? Edit, One curious fact about Joker's origins is that they're left up in the air. If Arthur had been abused so badly as a kid by his mom and her boyfriend, then why doesn't he remember, and why wasn't he taken away from her by child protective services? The second is that he could not have reloaded the weapon while also carrying his bag in the opposite hand. Also it's possible Arthur may have decided to not bother explaining why he had the gun because he felt (possibly correctly) that nobody would listen to him anyway. Belmont Lay Archived post. Arthur starts to get ready for his appearance on Murray's show and paints his face white. Also whenever Arthur's condition causes him to uncontrollably laugh, in the most inappropriate situations that angers people he didn't mean to offend, with it visibly distressing and physically hurting him. What Randall didnt think would happen, however, was that Joker would bring the gun into a childrens hospital. Edit, Yes, he smokes the American Spirit brand. Showing the clip of the lousy performance and then having Arthur give another lousy performance live would have been bad television, and Murray is, if nothing else, a good television host. When things go awry, Randall quickly (and successfully) tries to push the blame on Arthur, which is when Arthur realizes the true colors of Randall. He would have been separated from her as a child but, once he turned 18, if he wanted to live with his mother as soon as she was released nobody could stop that. It could just be a Joker.Note that this problem also occurred in the Batman film of 1989, in which the Joker was said to have killed Bruce Wayne's parents, when Bruce was only a child. Randall his clown colleague: Did Arthur actually kill this guy or was this scene also in his head? Just tried to build up something that we could relate to in these days and also have something related to the comic book series.Edit: Gotham is based on Chicago and Metropolis (where Superman/Clark Kent lives) is based on New York as per the DC wiki. Edit, In the movie Arthur is an adult. Whenever Arthur is walking down the streets of Gotham, why does he seems to stagger a bit on one of his legs? The exploration of Arthur Fleck (Joaquin Phoenix), a man disregarded by. In doing this, he kept Joker's attention on him and off the audience and other two guests. SPOILER: Did Murray deserve to die in the Joker movie? - Quora When Murray got shot, no security or police jumped Arthur. Joker cinematographer Lawrence Sher has answered the lingering question of whether Arthur Fleck killed his neighbor Sophie Dumond near the end of the blockbuster DC film. (D) Arthur being mentally ill and therefore a rather unreliable witness, he'd have a difficult time getting anyone to believe his testimony, especially when facing in court the (probably) more affluent and better educated friends and families and employers of the three men he killed. He basically celebrates that. While Fleck doesnt do anything particularly bad, hes creepy throughout the showdown. Edit, "comedy is subjective", It is sort of a truism but it does fit, some people like a certain kind of humor that can fall completely flat for others. Did he give the gun thinking that when Joker will be performing he will drop it - as it happened? Advertise with us Spoilers: What Happened to Zazie Beetz in 'Joker'? Does Joker Kill Sophie? Edit, The steep stairs are connected to Shakespeare and Anderson Avenues at West 167th Street in the Highbridge section of the Bronx, New York City. Why does Arthur kill his mother? He is a mentally unstable failed comedian who, following his great lack of success and respect, loses his sanity until he becomes a nihilistic and psychotic criminal known as the . It's a suicidal fantasy, which would explain why it quickly cuts to him lying on the bed. He had just called him to increase the ratings of his show by interviewing a person who had gone viral because of his weird behavior. Inspections have been carried out at the ferry terminal by Indonesian authorities. Todd revealed, that he tried to convince Joaquin several times, before Joaquin accepted the role. //]]> | Since Arthur is unreliable as a narrator (assuming that the end of the movie showing Arthur in the hospital is him having lost his mind and talking about his past), did he imagine killing Randall as payback?

Private Child Transportation Services, Tv Land Drama Pluto Tv Schedule, Abby Martin Parents, Where Did Fernando Tatis Jr Go To College, Articles W