sig p220 vs 1911 recoil

The SIG 220s, 226s and 1911s are all awesome. Learn how your comment data is processed. Factory replacement recoil spring guide rod for SIG GSR 1911 models. The P220 is no exception. The only change/improvements I made on any of my P series Sigs were flat triggers on curved trigger models and #10 Trijicon rear sights on the Legion .45 and 10mm as I don't like a combat hold. Both are absolutely fantastic firearms. Police chiefs had been leery about carrying cocked and locked guns. The P220 is a bit dated by todays standards but people still love the gun, and it has a worthy place in the history of modern combat handguns. It's beyond a stretch to call that an "evolution"they are different animals. No spam. Your email address will not be published. A 400-dollar SIG is hard to beat. After some time, the weapon was imported under SIGs trademark because of SIGs success and growth. One of those guns was a well-worn P220 European, the other, a brand new P220 American. While not so small overall as a snubby .38, it is very flat. It always had good sights compared to most of its competition. These handy units are the only part of a Sig P365 you need to go to a gun shop to receive. Grips, sights, trigger kits etc. SigTalk is a forum community dedicated to SIG Sauer enthusiasts. Find the right recoil spring & explore official SIG SAUER factory direct parts. This gun is remarkably simple. With an overall length of 8.3 inches and a weight of thirty-two ounces, the XD (M) is a surprisingly light and comfortable pistol. The P220 is 100% reliable with any 10mm ammo. (If you want a more direct comparison between the Legion and non-Legion Sigs, take a look at our review of the Sig P226 and P226 Legion.) The model we are reviewing today is a .45 ACP model. Four shots went into roughly 1-1/4 inches. (1) A fan of SIGs compact single-stack 9mm, Mullin added, Although the P220 is not as good as a P225, I would rate it the top weapon that I tested in .45 ACP. (Mullins emphasis.). SigTalk is a forum community dedicated to SIG Sauer enthusiasts. There is no comparison between the two in terms of format and function. The P220 always fit most hands well. The P220 has a separate breech block. The first thing that jumps out is the two-tone look is the result of combining an anodized barrel, action, and slide combined with a Flat Dark Earth alloy frame . Check and mate. The SIG P220 in its Combat variation is designed for service and protection. In the end, both platforms are really good choices. What did Sig have to do to the P220 to make it a modern fighting pistol? My biggest complaint is related to my preference for a nice high grip. There is no comparison between the two in terms of format and function. The Fora platform includes forum software by XenForo. Today, Im going to review two Viridian laser products: one for your pistol and one for your AR. Along with those I have four other 45acp 1911s. All pistols have drawbacks and shortcomings. In other words good workmanship is a plus but when coupled with cheesy materials and an inferior design it never has cut the mustard. Sig Sauer Recoil Springs - 14, 16, 18 and 20 Lbs.Fits all P220, P226, P227 models (DASA, SAO, Elite, Legion, 220/226 "S" etc.) My Colt is an early model blued steel model and my Sig does have an aluminum frame. Massad Ayoob confesses that the SIG P220 is his very favorite SIG pistol, and indeed, one of his all-time favorite handguns. Although even with people who should know better, the gun has always been rated high in Snob Appeal (only because it was made in Germany originally) reality is another story. Maybe you handled a norinco rip-off, but the P220 is a dream and 100% opposite of your tedious description. 85757. Ill get more into this aspect a little . Mfg: Viridian Weapon Technologies. Join Date: January 15, 2006. I now own and carry a 220 Elite Dark. By contrast, the P220 was much rounder and more friendly to the hand. Both are awesome handguns. We may earn a commission when you purchase through the links on our site. Trigger reset is more than a 1911, but less than a Glock. The use of a single stack does make it a bit dated compared to modern handguns, but SIG has introduced a double-stack .45 ACP called the P227 if you want a few more rounds. or quality 1911 (Awesome/Expensive!) Get em both. I have a three of Sig P220s to include a Dark Elite. Ive had both, for me, the sig is hands down the best platform foe ten mil. It is about the same weight as the six-shot Smith & Wesson Model 10 or Model 64 Military & Police revolver with a 2-inch barrel. I prefer the DA/SA feature of the P220, the decocker, and the lack of a manual safety. For starters, the P245 borrows the unique flat-wire recoil spring pioneered on the P239. Sorry, but John Moses Browning in all his wisdom still made you lower your hammer manually, which is less safe by definition. Thats cool; this article is my personal opinion. Those P220 variants are easier on those who cant wrap their heads around two different trigger pulls from one gun. The P220 Legion has been redesigned to bring 10mm stopping power to the common handgun buyer. There's nothing wrong with the original P220; it's a perfectly solid gunbut the Legion is better. Come join the discussion about Sig Sauer pistols and rifles, optics, hunting, gunsmithing, styles, reviews, accessories, classifieds, and more! I have to change recoil springs to go from modern weak 10mm to "real" 10mm in the Glock and the 1911. Sig P220 Legion Full-Size. And probably settle for a Ruger SR1911 just to get that into my collection. Have not had an issue with shooting either one and I enjoy both, fell in love with the P220 when they first came out. A Sig Sauer P220 only needs to be run one way: hammer down on a loaded chamber. The designation changed to Pistol, Caliber .45, Automatic, M1911A1 in the Vietnam War era. With a 3.9-inch barrel and weight of 30 ounces, the P220 carry is the ideal . Fire Control Unit is the term used by Sig to describe the bundle of parts the ATF considers the firearm. Done. Therefore, the P220 was created. You have entered an incorrect email address! While the world has moved to 9mm pistols and polymer-frame guns, the SIG P220 is a defiant old man telling kids to get off his lawn. The 1911 is a legendary handgun, and it has been offered in many variations since its introduction 108 years ago. They put an accessory rail on it. If you have any feedback or question about my articles, please submit it here, it's always appreciated! Save my name and email to use for future comments. Now lets take a look at the design defects of this handgun. I prefer the 220. 4. The G21 has a polymer frame; the SIG's is alloy. There was also the accuracy factor. I've really been giving it some hard thought lately as to the what good a handgun is doing me . The P220 has a 4.4-inch barrel and is an all-metal gun. Like the EAA pistol, Sig Sauer's P220 Legion uses a DA/SA trigger and has a stainless steel frame and slide. Posted: 7/29/2012 8:05:48 AM EDT. The P220 set the standard for decockers and positions it for easy thumb reach. It is probably the best DA self-loader aroundIn summary, the P220 is an excellent example of how good a DA auto can be. I have both a Colt Delta Elite and a. I checked my gun safe and I have to stand both corrected and chastised regarding my original post. This classic has been reborn, with the same quality, accuracy and reliability that the Swiss Army has relied on for decades. Recoil Spring Set - 1911 Ultra .45ACP . It was perfect, straight out of the box. Theres a time to do it out in the field and/or when youre in the comfort of your man cave.-Field stripping is not to be confused with detail stripping. The Fora platform includes forum software by XenForo. Nothing bit the shooter. Slim-ish width, great grip angle and comfortable Hogue rubber grips make it feel great in the hand. I immediately relegated the Colt to the safe (archives), and havent looked back. 1; 2; Next. 8. The weight of the duty belt is one reason why back problems in general and lower back problems in particular seem to be an occupational hazard of the street cop. He it is that shall come out of Jacob to rule, who has been set by the Father as king over Sion, his holy mount, and shall have the Gentiles for his inheritance, and the utmost parts of the earth for his possession. I cant argue the symbolism, patriotism, and outright hell YEAH! that holding a kickass 1911 brings forth. The full-length slide rails are on the inside of the frame, which lets the slide sit deeper, lowering the bore axis to reduce felt recoil and muzzle flip. From the world leader in firearms . Please consider supporting me on Patreon!https://www.patreon.com/jeffshootsstuffI apologize that this video was uploaded from an Android phone. (Though, oddly enough, 9mm, 10mm, .38 Super and .22LR are other available calibers for both pistols). I am wondering if I should go with a quality 1911 or the sig p220 and stick with the same design as my p226? Yell at me all you want, I know I'm right after years of using both platforms -- and here's my justification. It was so much fun shooting that after one shooting session I went out and bought a Sig P229, but I had wanted another P226 in .40 but the store didn't have one, but now I am glad because I like having the two different sizes. Recoil Spring Set - P220 Carry . The original P220 was a reverse engineered 9mm model which resulted in its jamming at the most inopportune times. The Marlin 1985 is an upscale, heavy-duty version of their excellent 336 lever rifle. The P series guns have also been put together with econo-grad stamped sheet metal roll pins which are not as strong or as durable as the old fashioned high quality solid pins. I considered buying another 1911 but then a buddy of mine got a P226 extreme and I liked it so much I bought my own. Other than that, this model is an exciting step back into the late 70s and early 80s. If you dont wanna carry the real thing that actually works as its supposed tom dont carry a gun. With the Sig, most generally you will not need a set of files to swap parts. Subsequent shots are single action, giving you a light and short trigger pull until the gun is decocked. With handguns from Glock or even SIGs own P320, I have to back my finger out just a bit to rest the tip of my finger on the trigger. Reliable, accurate, and affordable, the 336 in caliber .30-30 is a staple in the deer woods each fall. I love both my Sig Tacops 1911 and my P220 Carry Elite. As a modern combat handgun its lacking. This is where the slide impacts when cycling. The 1911 was never built for the round. It fires the much more powerful .45 ACP cartridge, but despite its greater power it kicks less and is more pleasant to shoot than most snubbies. Unsubscribe at any time. In fact, the P245 takes the exact same spring used on the .40/.357 P239s (and the .40/.357 Sig Pros). Posts: 2,550. It has a rounded beavertail and is comfortable even with a high, firm grip. SIG Sauer. While the P220 is mostly known as the 45 ACP SIG, it's been produced in a ton of different calibers, including 9mm, 7.65x21mm Parabellum, .38 Super, and of course, 10mm. I would suggest if you haven't shot a 1911, rent one and try it. In free states, the eight rounds of .45 ACP severely lacks when compared to the 21 rounds I can get in a CZ P09, or even the 13 rounds I can get in a Glock 21. All that didn.t have the more aggressive G10 grips also got those from Hogue. Im not saying that you need to be a rocket scientist to run a 1911, but it takes more far attention to the pistol, safety, and handling. Hi! You will not be regretting it. There are no points of pain when firing round after round. 5 Best .45 ACP Pistols, Sig Sauer P220: The Sig Sauer P220 Combat is a pistol with a super-light aluminum frame, which is quite different from other .45 ACPs and is very customizable. The history on those two pistols I cited doesn't change just because you don't like the narrative, and a supposedly 'newer, awesomer' version doesn't make the previous version less prone to failure with the full power 10mm ammo (Norma 10mm and other) the FBI and others were testing with at that time. Only our P320-F (Full-Size) guide rod and P320 X-Five (Full Size) include a 15-pound 1911 recoil spring. Your thoughts? When you buy a P220, you know youre getting a quality gun. However, they paid the price of a caliber that offered minimum acceptable power, especially when the ammunition was fired from a short barrel. What else would you need to fix?, Nothing! My model is very plain, and very much a 1970 combat pistol. A Colt all steel Delta Elite would be hard to beat. Description. The SIG Sauer P220 introduced the SIG Sauer system, which is more straightforward than the P210 and does away with the grooves in the slide and barrel as well as the locking lugs. Compact variants are popular civilian concealed carry weapons in the U.S. because of the design's relatively slim width and the stopping power[. Funny how that works when only one manufacturer makes a gun. I know the 1911 is Gods Gun (though I bet when I get to the Pearly Gates, Saint Peter will be rocking a Sig) and the physical manifestation of America! in forged steel. *Spoken like a good Beretta shooter bhp0!. Sig P220-P229-SP 2022-Sig 1911-M400. The 336 and its cousins have probably accounted for enough deer over the years to fill a decent-sized football stadium. Thankfully, Sig seems to have had access to a crystal ball. I don't think they have any 220. The pistol was later Americanized with a Browning-type magazine release. View Deal . Compared to the P210, the P220 is a far superior firearm in terms of performance and aesthetics. My fingertip falls perfectly on the trigger, but for many others, I imagine trigger reach is a bit far. Its a heavy beast best described as a boat anchor. Its beyond a stretch to call that an evolutionthey are different animals. ReliabilityThis first reason a Sig P220 is better than a 1911 is a no-brainer. The single action trigger has a slight bit of take up, but you meet the wall quickly. SIG also offers the P220 Legion in DA/SA and SAO, with the same differences between the versions as the P226 Legion. Or, hey, get yourself a P220SAO (single action only) or P220 with a DAK trigger. 1. Standard 23 grain hardball in both brass case and steel case has given me 100% reliability. Very interesting question! The gun lacks manual safety. Reducing the weight of the duty .45 from 39.5 ounces to 25.7 (the same round-count of the same ammunition adds the same weight to either) results in a 13.8-ounce weight saving almost a pound at a critical point. I apologize for the misinformation, guys. As you can probably tell, the P220 SAO is my favorite in either caliber. But the gun had other advantages, too. It holds eight rounds of .45 ACP in a single stack magazine. I may head to the range this weekend and rent a 1911. Just letting you know. Thus it was that the cops and the shooting public were delighted to discover that the SIG P220, which like the lightweight Commander had an aluminum frame, wasnt anywhere near as difficult to shoot as the alloy-framed Colt. Which models would you find comparable ? In this Article: Kimbers OriginsNowThe Micro 9The Micro 9 Up Close & PersonalI Like TheShooting The Micro 9How To Select Ammo For The Micro 9 A Quick PrimerCleaning/Reassembling The Micro 9And, In The End Kimber is a company that has had a rather rocky past. Just in case it doesnt, yknow, work all the time. Sig P220, 224, 226, M400 TREAD, 516 G2 Patrol SBR, 716i TREAD, MPX K, 1911 Emperor Scorpion Fastback, 1911 TACOPS Carry, 1911 . If you live in a state that has magazine restrictions the SIG P220s low capacity may be a perfect choice for a home defense gun. As a hammer-fired gun, a nice beavertail means you dont have to worry about hammer or slide bite with these guns. The gun weighs 1.9 pounds unloaded. In my own testing although accuracy was good (at least with the German Made guns) the P226 9mm was always inferior to old fashioned classic guns like the Original High Power or Neuhausen P210 or CZ 75 or THE FABULOUS STAR MODEL 30 which was the BEST HANDGUN OF THE 20TH/21st.CENTURY which actually endured 180,000 round wear tests, try that with any other modern plasticky or stamped sheet metal pistol. At one time, I had three Sig P220s of the same generation (P220s had slight generational changes to the slide and extractor setups over the years) and I conducted that very exercise. The SIG P220 Carry is an obvious commitment to handgun manufacture as there are many different versions of this handgun. The P220 weighs a tad less than a lightweight Commander, 25.7 ounces unloaded. Flawless and the weight results in 9mm-eque recoil. I wouldn't write that in stone but I do recall reading that. If you were in a situation where you knew people would be shooting back at you, and you could only choose between a Sig P220 or a 1911, both loaded with modern hollow point defense ammo, which would you grab? Since the heading question was about .45 ACP, I limited it to that. A lightweight service pistol is especially important in law enforcement. My 220 has been flawless from the first round. Itll probably keep you reasonably safe in a bullseye match but I still would lay odds that a nice P220 Match Elite will probably kick the crap out of a 1911 Gold Cup at the target range too. For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding. 50rd boxes of 230gr is still $25 here on base, so I'm "getting hammered" this upcoming holiday weekend. They will drag you down to their level and beat you with experience.". Sig Sauer P220 Legion . It is what it is. By. Add to Cart. We fixed it! But it is a lot to lug around for a day or two of hiking. Type 1911 into the search bar, Go ahead. $20.00. This is the correct-weight factory replacement recoil spring for SIG P220 pistols in .45 ACP and P226 pistols in .40 S&W / .357 SIG. I will champion the following statement till the day I die: Anything the 1911 can do, the Sig Sauer P220 can do better. I have twice put five rounds from a P220 into one inch at 25 yards. A forum community dedicated to SIG Sauer Pistols and SIG Sauer Rifles owners and enthusiasts. Sig also has had design changes to their extractors, long v/s short so here is another area to watch out for. Oddly enough I paid less than half for it than I did the Dan Wesson and it might have been a touch cheaper than the P220. When the cheesey stamped sheet metal roll pins are removed for cleaning of the frame or repair they will not go back in as tight and should be replaced. (I know, the heresy! The Sig is older but recently been refit with all new springs and bbl, comes with multiple sig mags. I will say this though ever since first shooting my sig I haven't shot any other handgun. Massad Ayoob is one of the world's outstanding handgunners and is the Director of Massad Ayoob Group. Check Price . 5127. - Color coded 14, 16, 18 and 20 lbs recoil springs for optimal tuning of recoil impulse with various types of ammunution. Come join the discussion about optics, hunting, gunsmithing, styles, reviews, accessories, classifieds, and more! Fits Sig Sauer P220 and P226 - Stainless. He deployed in 2009 to Afghanistan and again in 2011 with the 22nd MEU(SOC) during a record setting 11 months at sea. and been wanting it for several years but always out of stock. Do you think you could take those ten guns and disassemble them all and throw their parts in a pile, then make ten completely new, fully functional guns with those jumbled-up parts? Nearly all the advantages of a 1911 with the ability to rack and chamber check with the manual safety engaged. Taught me a lot about SIG at 45 caliber, and did nothing to take away from the appreciation I learned, FOR SIG, from a 9mm P239. In stainless, the full-size P220 is a fairly massive handgun, and feels far bigger and chunkier that the 1911. Even the Delta Elite made some frame modifications after the earlier models cracked. The Sig P220 and the 1911 are both . The pistol is a significant part of the load, and any reduction in weight is appreciated. The M1911 (also known as Colt 1911, or Colt Government) is a single-action, semi-automatic, magazine-fed, recoil-operated pistol chambered for the .45 ACP cartridge. It is a great and comfortable shooter. The SIG is a bigger frame, fatter grip, obviously very different trigger. I logged in searching for info on my own P220 an European model chambered in 9mmPara (yes, they dont make them anymore) bought in 1980. The Fora platform includes forum software by XenForo. I have been shooting 40 for years and looking for something else now. Extraordinarily accurate, very reliable, and easy to handle and shoot, one of the P220's cardinal attributes is the cartridge for which it is chambered: the .45 ACP. Its a massive gun thats heavy and wide and sports a very wide grip for a single stack gun. The only thing the P220 and 1911 share in common is caliber. In a fall or sudden impact the grips can shatter or crack and then the mainspring strut can become bent or even snapped in two putting the gun out of action. In fact, any 1911 that would be generally be considered to have the correct accepted upgrades to be a modern fighting pistol is so vastly removed from the original 1911A1 design that it could be considered a new design. The Commander, originally introduced in lightweight format in 1949, weighed 26.5 ounces unloaded and held the same number of .45, .38 Super, or 9mm rounds as the P220. Taking the gun apart is very easy, and SIG makes it simple. Receive exclusive gun deals once a week and all our great reviews right in your inbox. The main spring of this gun is a throw back to one of the biggest turkeys of a handgun ever invented the P38. -. Naturally it is not made anymore because it was quality. The use of a single stack does make it a bit dated compared to modern handguns, but SIG has introduced a double-stack .45 ACP called the P227 if you want a few more rounds. April 22, 2023 03:35 AM. The P220 was built to meet and exceed rigorous military standards. This part will help keep your Sig Sauer Firearm in top shooting condition. The SIG-Sauer pistols are famous for accuracy across the board, but the P220 may be the most accurate of them all. Interestingly enough in the United States, the P220 is mostly known for being a .45 ACP handgun. My friend Chuck Taylor is one of the leading authorities on combat handguns and the author of a great many articles and multiple books on the topic. Next, eject the magazine. It will probably need a fluff n buff to make it feed defensive ammo, too. Next time I will verify what I wrote before posting it. I'm Mike, one of the oldest writer of Sniper Country! And, of course, there was the reliability factor. kygunco.com . "Si Vis Pacem, Para Bellem" ~If you wish for peace, prepare for war~. It also has a fully adjustable rear sight, and the magazine holds 14 rounds of ammo. The frame of the P series guns is made of aluminum and as every knows who has used both aluminum framed versus steel frame guns the aluminum frame guns are inferior in regards to losing accuracy because they wear away quicker and are damaged more easily in an accidental dropping or fall. The Sig P220 field stripping obviously is a breeze compared to the 1911. It is a fantastic gun for the range and to experience a Swiss 1911 in many ways. This means its short, and very well designed. Recoil Spring Set - P220 .45ACP, P226 . document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. During the time after World War I, there were attempts to make the 1911 into a more accurate handgun, primarily for use at Camp Perry. Get the 76th edition of the World's Greatest Gun Book. Did you hear that? if I were in the market again, the P220 is by NO means lacking in the .45 arena and capacity is a non-existent problem, as the ONLY ones who require more rounds are carrying an AR15 or a 12 gauge. It comes down to whats more important for you, reliability/accuracy/ergonomics, or capacity/size? Whats the difference in hotter 10mm? Has a higher bore axis, parts and mags are expensive. FYI, with heavy loads the SigP220 is the more comfortable pistol to shoot, much more comfortable grips and ergomatics! Because it was reverse engineered it also could not function with sharp shouldered lead bullets like the super accurate Keith 200 grain semi-was cutter. Save Compare. The SIG Sauer P220 is one of the few single-stack, all-steel guns still holding on in the modern age. The slide lock position is towards the rear of the gun, which creates an issue for many who like a nice high thumbs-forward grip. What a wonderful gun to run. Thanks for the input so far. The Sig P220 field stripping obviously is a breeze compared to the 1911.The main objective is just quick disassembly, inspection and cleaning.-However, detailing the P220 guts is a bitch to do, which requires specialize tools and require more frequent care. The 1911 depends on a barrel link which can also fail. The triggers are almost always quite-good-to-excellent for a DA/SA gun. Its certainly a weapon made for its time, and that time has long passed. My GunsAmerica search brought up the following: Smith & Wesson, two Colts, Kimber, CSC Arms, Springfield, Dan Wesson, Detonics, Taurus, and Ruger. Come join the discussion about optics, hunting, gunsmithing, styles, reviews, accessories, classifieds, and more! Romans 1:16- "For I am not ashamed of the Gospel of Christ" Do we not read throughout the Scriptures that Christ is the King? . He serves as an NRA certified pistol instructor and teaches concealed carry classes. In stock. In conclusion a Colt/Browning this gun certainly is not and never can come close to being ever. 4. It is in fact a corrosion-resistant PVD coating in "Legion Gray.". Once the first shot had been fired, it went to single-action, where the trigger press was a clean, easy 4 to 6pounds or so. It handles great and the lightweight slide makes . GRD-SIG-22F-SS. Now lets face facts no company these days uses quality parts unless they absolutely have to and Sig would have never dropped the econo-grade stamped slide because they wanted too. My Sig P220 SAO 10mm pistol does have a steel frame. Get gun deals, hand's on reviews, educational content and updates on law changes daily! With a hair more pressure you get the trigger break. I have to change recoil springs to go from modern weak 10mm to "real" 10mm in the Glock and the 1911. "A patriot must always be ready to defend his country against his government", You really need to consider that the 1911. The Rifle section is dedicated to James Henry Mason, aka forum member "horse"; shooter, collector and rifle authority, who left us too soon. The SIG Sauer P220 is a semi-automatic pistol. But first-rate quality, very solid feel.

Disadvantages Of Temperature Control System, Danny Fairbrass Illness, Did Rexella Van Impe Have A Stroke, Greensboro, Nc Recent Arrests, Articles S